First Niagara Bank Address: 1609 Main St, Pleasant Valley, NY 12569 Phone: (845) 635-3411 Payment: Banks, E Commerce, Safe Deposit Box-Rental, First Niagara Bank Other Businesses: Citizens Bank at 17 North Ave, Pleasant Valley, NY 12569 Chase Bank at 1600 Main St, Pleasant Valley, NY 12569 Quattro's Hunting Supplies at 107 Tinkertown Rd, Pleasant Valley, NY 12569 Hickory Ridge Farm at 235 Plass Rd, Pleasant Valley, NY 12569